Cakes & Pies

Cakes 

Our frozen custard cakes are perfect for any size party. Call our cake-making experts today to customize your order! Please allow 24 hours for cake orders. Short-notice orders also available.

Pies

We have a variety of homemade pies available in every store. Below are the most popular selections, but custom orders are always available.

Turtle Pie

We begin with a shortbread piecrust and ladle in a layer of hot fudge sauce. Next, a generous handful of Spanish peanuts gives the pie that sweet and salty bite. Our Abbott’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard fills the pie and is then topped with more hot fudge, peanuts and a cherry. Wow!

Peanut Butter Cup Pie

We use our special shortbread piecrust and load it up with hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, vanilla or chocolate frozen custard, and top it off with peanut butter cups.

Oreo^® Cookie Pie

Our shortbread piecrust serves as the base for this tasty concoction. We pile it high with vanilla or chocolate frozen custard, crushed Oreo cookies and chocolate sauce.

Pumpkin Pie

Available seasonally.